adam zivo: carney's platform a failure on crime and drugs
over a decade, liberal bail, sentencing and drug policies helped create an epidemic
4 minute read
toronto police were on the scene of a home on fairholme ave. east of the allen rd., and lawrence ave. west, where a man was found shot dead on monday dec. 9, 2024. j
jack boland
/
postmedia
canadians are exasperated with the crime, violence and drug use that has swept through their cities over the past decade. while the liberals have promised to fix these issues should they be reelected, it is clear from their platform that they aren’t taking this file seriously.
the trudeau government’s failures here cannot be understated. the country is awash with fentanyl and over 50,000 canadians have lost their lives to opioids since 2016. organized gangs are running amok and violent crime has exploded to levels unseen since the pre-harper era, reversing what had previously been a 20-year downward trend.
it is clear that canada’s lax justice system is largely to blame for this. bail has been granted too generously to dangerous predators, and, when convictions are secured, our judiciary often imposes scandalously inadequate punishments that neither deter anti-social behaviour nor isolate violent offenders from the rest of society. this, in turn, has undermined law enforcement more generally, because there is little point in arresting criminals in a “catch and release” system.
why is our justice system so broken? you can blame the liberals’ passage of bill c-75 in 2019, which greatly loosened bail conditions and mandated that arrested individuals be released as soon as possible. then there was bill c-5 in 2022, which removed mandatory minimum sentences for drug traffickers and imposed greater use of house arrest in lieu of incarceration.
advertisement
concurrently, the liberals negligently allowed illicit drugs and chemical precursors (which are used to make fentanyl) to enter our borders and ports almost unabated. worse yet, they embraced unscientific harm reduction experiments — such as drug decriminalization and “safer supply” — to the near-total exclusion of drug prevention and treatment, only to belatedly change course once it became undeniable that these policies actually exacerbate addiction and crime.
if liberal leader mark carney is elected next week, will he rectify his party’s mistakes? probably not.
with respect to crime, his platform inexplicably spotlights gun control and proposes extending trudeau’s gun buyback program. the impact of these policies will almost certainly be negligible since criminals predominantly use firearms smuggled from the united states and legal gun owners rarely commit crimes. academic experts and police leaders have also disavowed the buyback program, now floundering in its fifth year, as ineffective and wasteful.
trudeau championed these policies for a decade while failing to curb violent crime, so why does carney expect to see different results?
the liberals further want individuals who are charged with violent or gang-related car thefts, home invasions and human trafficking to face a “reverse onus” during bail hearings — meaning that they must prove why they should be released into the public, instead of the crown proving why they should be detained.
advertisement
however, reverse onus is already required for many of these crimes, and expanding its use does nothing to address the dysfunctional bail framework that arose thanks to bill c-75. absent wider reforms, judges will still be encouraged to grant the most lenient bail conditions possible and to coddle defendants from disadvantaged backgrounds. because of these norms, dangerous criminals are already being granted easy bail regardless if reverse onus is in play — so it is hard to see how this constitutes a real solution.
for repeat car thieves and home invaders specifically, carney wants sentencing judges to emphasize denunciation and deterrence, which should naturally lead to harsher punishments. this is a positive step forward, but the scope here is oddly limited (why not apply this to other offenses?) and it is uncertain what new sentencing ranges would emerge afterwards. ergo, this proposal is too weak and unpredictable to sufficiently address an urgent problem.
carney wants to permit consecutive sentencing for serious and violent offenders, which is great. yet, stacking long sentences atop each other means that some offenders could face life without parole, which the supreme court ruled unconstitutional in 2022. he would thus probably have to invoke the charter of rights and freedoms’ notwithstanding clause to fulfill his promise, mirroring what conservative leader pierre poilievre has promised to do with his own consecutive sentencing proposals.
advertisement
but carney criticized poilievre’s openness to using the clause, in this specific context no less, as a “dangerous step” and “slippery slope.” is he unaware of the constitutional implications of his own policies, or is he being hypocritical or disingenuous?
the platform also calls for investing in the public prosecution services of canada so that it can better tackle organized crime and drug trafficking. that’s another good move, but, unfortunately, bolstering prosecutorial capacity is moot without serious sentencing and bail reform.
carney wants to train 1,000 border officers, armed with new scanners and other resources, to target suspicious shipments entering the country. he also wants to hire 1,000 rcmp officers to fight modern threats (i.e. cybercrime, foreign interference, drug trafficking) while making it easier to search canada post mail for fentanyl and other contraband. these are great ideas! but why didn’t the liberals do this years ago? can we trust that they will act with urgency?
beyond crime, carney’s platform says almost nothing about drugs. safer supply? decriminalization? supervised consumption sites? all conspicuously omitted. there is $500 million promised for drug treatment, without further details. that’s inexcusable. after decades of liberal mismanagement, canadians deserve, and should demand, more specificity.
advertisement
national post
share story
